| Mark Procyk | 8 | 18 | From 05/17/09 to 08/09/09 |
| Eric Lanting | 7 | 13 | From 05/17/09 to 07/12/09 |
| Eric Drucker | 4 | 13 | From 07/26/09 to Season End |
| Eric Drucker | 3 | 9 | From 06/07/09 to 06/21/09 |
| Matt Wade | 3 | 5 | From 07/12/09 to 08/02/09 |
| David Tropea | 3 | 4 | From 05/17/09 to 06/14/09 |
| Ron Kewish | 3 | 3 | From 08/02/09 to Season End |
| Ron Kewish | 2 | 4 | From 06/28/09 to 07/12/09 |
| Eric Lanting | 2 | 3 | From 08/09/09 to Season End |
| Derek Webber | 2 | 3 | From 06/07/09 to 06/14/09 |